Tuesday, April 22, 2008

Fug the READ poster - Christina Ricci


Everything about this poster scares me. First and foremost, there's the book. That's The Fountainhead, in case you left your magnifying glass in your other bag. I checked, and there's no professional reason why Christina Ricci should be holding onto this punishing screed of a novel, which has persuaded generations of callow, overprivileged undergraduates that their self-centeredness is justified. It's pretty close to an evil book. I think it's interesting that ALA responded to her choice by airbrushing up a gritty, airless-looking canyon of commerce as a backdrop.

Then you have that outfit. The skirt screams "hooker" and the sweater protests, "student." The shoes are the tie-breaker. Either tuition is expensive enough to make a girl compromise her morals, or the book is a prop to catch the eye of the fetish-y businessman looking to kill time before he catches the Metro North.

As if little Christina isn't attractive enough on her own. A talented, versatile actress with perfect skin, a beautiful face, and terrifying eyes, the girl has nonetheless experimented with every moderately-to-excessively slutty look under the sun. It's mystifying. At her best, she looks like a Blythe doll, wee, coy, and adorable. At her worst... well, it gets pretty bad.

This poster is no longer available, says the ALA website. Luckily, the same can be said for this version of Christina Ricci. Nobody outside of Japan, where it has become so integral to the culture that it has lost its meaning - should attempt this look.

I suggest an alternate city scene for our grown-up Wednesday Addams -
sitting on a bench in Bryant Park on a sunny afternoon, smoking, surreptitiously drinking vodka and cranberry out of a thermos, and making mean comments about the fratty media kids eating their lunches and discussing their handbags - the kind of people who read The Fountainhead in college and bought Ayn Rand's bullshit.

7 comments:

  1. I love your READ poster commentaries! I agree it's shocking how many of them are terrible, especially sad because of how many great celebrities they get to support it.

    Tis a pity. Ricci is in my top five of amazingly cool and talented and pretty people I admire. Just so not a good usage of her style. :(

    ~Heather cj

    ReplyDelete
  2. Wow. I love it when librarians--the gatekeepers of freedom--brand books they philosophically disagree with as "evil." Hey, I have an idea: let's ban it!

    ReplyDelete
  3. No, no, no, no, no, you've got it all wrong. Clearly I'M the one who ought to be banned. A librarian with a strong opinion about a book?!

    I must have missed the day in library school where they taught us that all books are to be revered equally lest the fires of freedom sputter and go out.

    ReplyDelete
  4. That's right actually: they didn't teach us in library school that all books are to be revered in the name of freedom--just "progressive" ones!

    My main reason for commenting though is that I don't think Rand's philosophy--that we shouldn't expect others to live/pay for our lives--is "evil." It truly scares me when educated people call this idea b.s.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I would tend to agree that book is evil, simply because a lot of otherwise intelligent people read Rand's crap and then worship and evangelize it, acting as though it's a groundbreaking paean to self-sufficiency, when in fact it is a tedious one to selfishness and arrogance.

    Capitalism, even Rand's version, only exists in a society. If you think you can become a millionaire without a whole bunch of people to set up a mercantile and banking system, more power to you.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Yeah yeah all this Rand vs. Donne stuff is grand and all, but let's not lose sight of the real controversy... the schoolgirl hooker look: empowering or exploitative?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Oh, good, it's not just me that hated Rand's book.

    As for Ricci's outfit, I personally wouldn't wear those light-colored shoes with it. That seems to fall under the category of "different for different's sake." She needs some black, high-heeled Mary Janes to pull off the "sexy schoolgirl" look.

    ReplyDelete